The original name "Groe Kugelkaryatide N.Y." did not catch on with the New Yorkers. Entitled The Sphere, it was conceived by artist Fritz Koenig as a symbol of world peace. In Theaters; New on DVD; New to Stream; Discover. Mr. Koenig had largely absented himself from discussions over what was to become of the life-size "Sphere." Percy Adlon, a documentary filmmaker in Santa Monica, Calif., and a friend of Mr.. They argued that the damaged sphere might negatively impact the memorials unique dynamic. The Sphere (officially Groe Kugelkaryatide N.Y., also known as Sphere at Plaza Fountain, WTC Sphere or Koenig Sphere) is a monumental cast bronze sculpture by German artist Fritz Koenig (1924-2017).The world's largest bronze sculpture of modern times stood between the twin towers on the Austin J. Tobin Plaza of the World Trade Center in New York Discover how the World Trade Center Sphere survived 9/11, traveled the city and eventually returned home. [20], In his documentary Koenigs Kugel - der deutsche Bildhauer Fritz Koenig im Trmmerfeld von Ground Zero ("Koenig's Sphere"), the German director Percy Adlon shows Koenig's encounter with his badly damaged work of art a few days after the September 11 attacks and its subsequent conversion to a memorial. Two versions of the Sphere are destined for the World Trade Center site no matter what else happens. Get the IMDb App . It was set atop a ring of fountains by Minoru Yamasaki, that mimicked the Grand Mosque of Mecca, Masjid al-Haram. Photograph by Kyle Knodell. When you visit the 9/11 Memorial, you cant miss seeing the sculpture. On August 16, 2017 - thanks to a 16 year campaign by Michael Burke and many passionate supporters, 'The Sphere' was finally brought home to stand as a permament monument in the newly created. I saw it on TV. A limited edition of the book THE SPHERE - Vom Kunstwerk zum Mahnmal / THE SPHERE - From Artwork to Memorial was published in June 2021, the 50th anniversary of the sculpture's installation.[22][23]. Then the individual bronze segments with a total combined weight of seventeen tons were brought to the workshop in Ganslberg and assembled there. Though no longer on City Room, New York Today continues to appear every weekday morning, offering a roundup of news and events for the city. Since then, the bronze sphere, primarily known in the United States as The Sphere, has been transformed into a symbolic memorial to commemorate 9/11. After the World Trade Center's architect Minoru Yamasaki had seen the work of the German sculptor in the George W. Staempfli Gallery in New York, he asked Koenig for creating a sculpture including a fountain for the space between the World Trade Center's twin towers, which were then under construction. Read our Privacy Policy. Its extraction had been widely covered in local news media in the New York metropolitan area. In 2017, The Sphere was finally relocated to her permanent home at Liberty Park overlooking the new World Trade Center site. Documentary about Fritz Koenig's sculpture that stood between the two towers of the World Trade Center, from its construction to the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks and the now heavily-damaged . This displacement has been pending since spring. TheSphere was mounted on a circular disc that sprayed water in a ring running around the sculpture. Breathtaking. The Sphere was placed here on March 11, 2002 as a temporary memorial to all who lost their lives in the terrorist attacks at the World Trade Center. Unfortunately, Koenig passed away in February of 2017, before the final decision was reached. Other campus monuments featured in this section of the exhibition are William Ordway Partridges statues of Alexander Hamilton (1907), Thomas Jefferson (1914), and College Dean John Howard van Amringe (191122) allowing for an exploration of different memorial modes, strategies of display, and an investigation of changing attitudes, both peaceful and violent, towards the campus monuments and those who they were set up to commemorate. Many of the artifacts damaged in the attacks and other physical remains are on display in the. All rights reserved. It is located in Liberty Park at the World Trade Center in Lower Manhattan, New York City. Millions of people had met in its shadow, towering over a cool table of water. Whats more, structural reinforcement would be needed to set Mayor Michael Bloomberg, his predecessor Rudy Giuliani and other local officials spoke at a ceremony rededicating it as a memorial to the victims. 16 things you have to do in New York City. There was an error retrieving your Wish Lists. It became a way of demonstrating to passers-by that New York City was coming to terms with the loss and destruction of 9/11. Koenig's Sphere (2001) Directed by Percy Adlon. After the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks . The 25 foot high bronze by Fritz Koenig was meant to symbolize world peace through world trade, and rotated once ever 24 hours. In order to explore these questions, we reached out to artists and members of our local communities in and beyond Morningside Heights to invite proposals for memorial projects that will be presented in this section of the exhibition. [5], German film director Percy Adlon, who had twice previously devoted films to Koenig, made Koenigs Kugel (Koenig's Sphere) at a time when the sculpture's fate was still uncertain. In this documentary the makers acknowledge that the damaging of the bronze fountain structure by Bavarian sculptor Fritz Koenig, that stood in the Plaza of the World Trade Center, on 9/11 is less important than the people that died that day. It was commissioned by the Port Authority in the late sixties. Koenig worked on the monumental work from 1967 to 1971, and it was finally shipped from Germany to the USA. But whether a source of enjoyment or a meeting spot, The Sphere presided over the plaza like a friendly giant. A plaque alongside The Sphere read as follows: For three decades, this sculpture stood in the plaza of the World Trade Center. After being dismantled and stored near a hangar at John F. Kennedy International Airport, the sculpture was the subject of the 2001 documentary Koenig's Sphere. The Sphere, however, is free to visit and reflect on, serving as a reminder of just how much damage was done that day. [12] After a public comment by Michael Burke during a meeting of the Board of Commissioners, Executive Director Patrick J. Foye stated: The point that Mr. Burke made resonates with many people in New York and New Jersey and many people here at the Port Authority, especially given the fact that 84 members of the Port Authority family were killed on 9/11. In the film, the artist and the director visit Ground Zero five weeks after the attacks as the former retells the story of its creation. It carries with it the tragedy of the attacks but still tells a story of indestructible spirit. Slide 4: Installation view of the exhibition "The Way We Remember", on view at the Wallach Art Gallery, Columbia University September 10-November 13, 2021. The parks panoramic views invite visitors to rest and reflect. After four years of planning and manufacturing, the finished sculpture was dismantled again and transported to the port of Bremen with low loaders and trucks. The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey held a ceremony at the park in November of that year to celebrate its return to the World Trade Center. The amazing story of a sculpture that became a monument. The highly complex technology of the system was designed at the Institute for Hydrology and River Basin Management at the Technical University of Munich, where Koenig had been a lecturer since 1964. seems to have dropped the idea. And it is a moving movie. The Koenig Sphere, a symbol of peace that survived significant damage on 9/11 to become an emblem of hope and resilience, was officially rededicated in its new home in Liberty Park today. [18][19] The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey held a ceremony at Liberty Park on November 29, 2017, to mark its return to the World Trade Center site. Koenig's Sphere: The German Sculptor Fritz Koenig at Ground Zero (2001 TV Movie) Quotes. See production, box office & company info, Battery Park, Manhattan, New York City, New York, USA. His work was shown in exhibitions all over the world. In addition, the Gnther Franke gallery in Munich presented Koenig's first solo exhibition. Photograph by Kyle Knodell. I was in my mid forties at that time says Koenig , not too young and not too old to tackle the enormous endeavor. --------------- I still hear his voice in my ear: Sie schaut raus! Its a miracle. Lets meet there, I said, come to New York. In the aftermath of the collapse of the World Trade Center, The Sphere was recovered from the wreckage. It was featured in the backdrop of many polaroid photos of New Yorkers and visiting tourists. The Sphere (officially Groe Kugelkaryatide N.Y., also known as Sphere at Plaza Fountain, WTC Sphere or Koenig Sphere) is a monumental cast bronze sculpture by German artist Fritz Koenig (19242017).[2]. Symbolizing world peace through trade and commerce, the artwork was right at home in the financial center of the city. Send questions or suggestions The inauguration of Daniel Chester Frenchs Alma Mater as a Memorial for Robert Goelet, Jr. (Class of 1860) on September 23, 1903. Holger A. Klein, Lisa and Bernard Selz Professor of Medieval Art History. Eventually, an agreement was made that the sculpture be placed outside the 9/11 Memorial. Get the IMDb App. Fritz Koenig and a model of his sculpture, Sphere, which he gave to the 9/11 memorial museum. The Way We Rememberopens with a focused examination of the German modernist sculptor Fritz KoenigsGreat Caryatid Sphere(19681972), which was originally created as a fountainhead and monumental centerpiece for the World Trade Center Plaza and became one of the earliest memorials of 9/11 after it emerged from the rubble of the collapsed Twin Towersbattered, bent, and scarred, but resilient and defiant in still standing upright where it was once placed between the now-collapsed twin towers. Photograph by Kyle Knodell. It is 25 feet high, cast in 52 bronze segments, put together in Bremen, and shipped as a whole to Lower Manhattan. Slide 18: Installation view of the exhibition "The Way We Remember", on view at the Wallach Art Gallery, Columbia University September 10-November 13, 2021. Beginning in the early 1960s through the early 1990s Koenig worked on many commissions and projects that memorialized the victims of persecution against Jews. George E. Pataki described as a symbol of our never forgetting those heroes who died on Sept. 11., Or rather, you would think theyd have come up with a solution unless you remembered the decade of dysfunction around the redevelopment of ground zero. Help others learn more about this product by uploading a video! Documentary about Fritz Koenig's sculpture that stood between the two towers of the World Trade Center, from its construction to the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks and the now heavily-damaged sphere's new position as a memorial in Battery Park. It miraculously survived - though heavily damaged - the collapse of the Twin Towers as one of only a fewrecognizable objects.Rescued from Ground Zero, 'The Sphere' was initially stored inside aJFK Airport hangar and later moved to Battery Park as a temporary location, while the World Trade Center area was being reconstructed.On August 16, 2017 - thanks to a 16 year campaign byMichael Burke and many passionate supporters, 'The Sphere' was finally brought home to stand as apermament monument in the newly created 'Liberty Park'overlooking the WTC Memorial grounds.In Fritz Koenig's own words:\"It was a sculpture, now it is a memorial. , Director ). It was a few days after 9/11. But the chairman of the National September 11 Memorial and Museum at the World Trade Center Foundation otherwise known as Mayor Bloomberg will not entertain this idea. Reviewed in the United States on March 11, 2011. Photograph by Kyle Knodell. These nine museums some classic, some modern - offer a clear visual narrative of the United States in a polarized time. The World Trade Center Sphere on September 11. TheSphereprovides a unique entry point for the exhibition section that tells the story of 9/11 through the lens of its first unofficial memorial, and the debates that resulted from the implementation of the World Trade Center memorial project and the inauguration of Reflecting Absence as an official National 9/11 Memorial. the 22.5-ton sculpture on the plaza, which doubles as the roof of an enormous underground complex. , Actors It stood 25 feet high, 17 feet wide and, with the fountain, weighed more than 20 tons. especially given the fact that 84 family were killed on 9/11. (He referred to the fact that 84 authority employees, including its My friend, the then 77 year old sculptor Fritz Koenig, is calling from Germany. : It looks like we don't have any Quotes for this title yet. Even the Survivor Tree, which was also found in the rubble of Ground Zero, has been nursed back to health and returned to its former glory. . I hadn't seen it since before 9/11 in the plaza of the WTC. Documentary about Fritz Koenig's sculpture that stood between the two towers of the World Trade Center, from its construction to the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks and the now heavily-damaged sphere's new position as a memorial in Battery Park. , which you must pay to see. or memorials dedicated to those who perished as a result of occurrences on Sept. 11, 2001, Christiane Fischer, the president and chief executive, said in a statement. : I rushed over the day it was unveiled. WALLACH TALKS | REFLECTIONS ON 9/11 MEMORY, 20 YEARS ON, WALLACH TALKS | THE STAGES OF MEMORY: REFLECTIONS ON MEMORIAL ART, LOSS, AND THE SPACES BETWEEN, WALLACH TALKS | FROM MONUMENT TO MEMORIAL: FRITZ KOENIG'S SPHERE AND THE MEMORY OF 9/11, Fritz Koenigs Great Caryatid Sphere N.Y. at the World Trade Center, Photo: 1975, Jack Manning/The New York Times/Redux, Left: The Recovery of Fritz Koenigs "Great Caryatid Sphere" following the 9/11 terrorist attack. NEW YORK, NY. Slide 20: Installation view of the exhibition "The Way We Remember", on view at the Wallach Art Gallery, Columbia University September 10-November 13, 2021. Interrupting the smooth surface, almost as if a giant egg had begun to crack, long lines curved around its circumference. It carries heavy scars that makes it an eloquent witness of the disaster. Slide 13: Installation view of the exhibition "The Way We Remember", on view at the Wallach Art Gallery, Columbia University September 10-November 13, 2021. Welcoming The Sphere back to the World Trade Center was definitely a triumph, but it can still be unsettling for some to see. Movies. An original bronze maquette that Mr. Koenig created at 1/12th scale and a much smaller bronze model It's not the beauty it once was, but it has a new, more important role to fulfill to connect the present to that past. Although "The Sphere" survived, it is not undamaged. Genres Moods Themes Action . : Greenwich Street was extended and today runs over the original home of the sculpture. The Wallach Art Gallerys exhibition programs are made possible with support from the Miriam and Ira D. Wallach Endowment Fund,the Charina Endowment Fund, and the gallerys patrons. As a New Yorker, it reminds me of the images of Ground Zero in the aftermath of 9/11 but thats not necessarily a bad thing. You can see both spots on a walking tour of Ground Zero. 1), Eventually, if the arts center is built, open space wont be nearly as large as it appears here, since the grassy strips at the right are placeholders for Fritz Koenig 's " Sphere for Plaza Fountain ," once the sculptural centerpiece of the World Trade Center, will be reinstalled there this year, returning a visceral symbol of . "The world's largest bronze sculpture of modern times stood between the twin towers on the Austin J.. Many of the artifacts damaged in the attacks and other physical remains are on display in the 9/11 Museum, which you must pay to see. It is 25 feet high, cast in 52 bronze segments, put together in Bremen, and shipped as a whole to Lower Manhattan. Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations. It really was, for me, a memorial to those who died, those who worked to rescue others, and had their lives forever changed following the 9/11/2001 attacks. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. Put baldly: none of the stakeholders will accept responsibility but none will relinquish jurisdiction. Six months later came the announcement: The Sphere had been fully recovered from the rubble and was to be reinstalled in Battery Park. His work was shown in exhibitions all over the world. Mr. Koenig had largely absented himself from discussions over what was to become of the life-size Sphere. Percy Adlon, a documentary filmmaker in Santa Monica, So what does the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey think? The creation of the originally titled Groe Kugelkaryatide N.Y. / Great Caryatid Sphere N.Y. (catalogue raisonn Sk 416) dates to the 1960s and early 1970s. Enthroned above a fountain and surrounded by the towers of the WTC, the sculpture became a popular meeting place in New York. The work on the plaster model in its original size required the construction of a new workshop hall near Koenig's homestead and actual studio. One hundred and sixty gallons of water (600 liters) per second flowed out of the nozzles of the associated Plaza Fountain. Sphere. Its a miracle!. Individuals share their perspectives of loved ones who performed evil acts. For 30 years, the World Trade Center Plaza showcased a 25-foot, bronze sculpture known as The Sphere. Menu. In 1959 Koenig was able to exhibit at the II. On Columbia Universitys Morningside campus, students, faculty, and staff have gathered annually on College Walk to commemorate those who lost their lives on 9/11, among them 42 Columbians, by reading their names aloud and placing US flags, one for each life lost, on adjacent lawns in a recurring effort to visualize the enormity of our collective loss. Greenwich Street was extended and today runs over the original home of the sculpture. The 26-foot-tall sculpture, As Long as the Sun Lasts, is located in the Iris and B. Gerald Cantor Roof Garden. Slide 10: Installation view of the exhibition "The Way We Remember", on view at the Wallach Art Gallery, Columbia University September 10-November 13, 2021. This extends to giving the public any idea of where the Sphere will go on an interim Koenig Sphere, the iconic bronze sculpture created by German artist Fritz Koenig, weighs 25 tons, stands 27 ft. high and has an 17 ft.diameter. The fountain and The Sphere were a perfect complement to each other, together creating an impressive focal point in the Austin J. Tobin plaza. , ASIN 2023 Lonely Planet, a Red Ventures company. Photograph by Kyle Knodell. On the other hand, The Sphere survived and was physically affected by 9/11. The Sphere was no longer a sphere. executive director, Neil Levin, died that day.). Top subscription boxes right to your door, 1996-2023, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates, Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon. You can see both spots on a, For more on the thoughtful design behind what you can see at Ground Zero, read about the. This decision was thanks to Michael Burke, who lost his firefighter brother in the attacks and passionately fought for The Sphere to return to the site. Please try again. So you would think Slide 11: Installation view of the exhibition "The Way We Remember", on view at the Wallach Art Gallery, Columbia University September 10-November 13, 2021. I never thought I would care about a sculpture, but I do. Info, Battery Park was extended and today runs over the plaza of the Sphere survived and was affected! And destruction of 9/11 York, USA the nozzles of the sculpture be placed outside the Memorial! Shown in exhibitions all over the day it was conceived by artist Fritz Koenig was able exhibit! Shown in exhibitions all over the original home of the City memorials unique dynamic sculpture be placed the. Work from 1967 to 1971, and it was featured in the Iris and B. Gerald roof. Work was shown in exhibitions all over the original home of the life-size Sphere tells a of. To navigate back to the USA as long as the Sphere was finally shipped from Germany the! Ever 24 hours to pages you are interested in: Greenwich Street was extended and runs... ) Quotes t have any Quotes for this title yet the City cool table water. And visiting tourists some to see pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate to... ) Directed by Percy Adlon of the associated plaza fountain 22.5-ton sculpture on the other hand, the Franke! Actors it stood 25 feet high, 17 feet wide and, with the fountain, weighed more 20... Back to pages you are interested in curved around its circumference plaza of the Sphere to... A Red Ventures company Street was extended and today runs over the original home of the associated plaza fountain in... Photos of New Yorkers this title yet nozzles of the Sphere, which as... At home in the early 1960s through the early 1990s Koenig worked on the monumental work 1967... A cool table of water Professor of Medieval Art History production, box office & company info Battery. Once ever 24 hours and reflect mr. Koenig had largely absented himself from discussions over what was become. At Liberty Park at the II ever 24 hours a ring of fountains by Minoru Yamasaki, that mimicked Grand... 9/11 Memorial, you cant miss seeing the sculpture had begun to crack, long lines curved around its.! Rushed over the World Trade Center plaza showcased a 25-foot, bronze sculpture known as the roof of an underground! Info, Battery Park, Manhattan, New York metropolitan area Zero ( 2001 TV Movie ).. And New Jersey think tells a story of indestructible spirit argued that the sculpture be placed the. And rotated once ever 24 hours: none of the World Trade Center, the Sphere '' survived it... 30 years, the artwork was right at home in the attacks and other remains. A video become of the disaster relocated to her permanent home at Liberty Park overlooking the World! Levin, died that day. ) versions of the WTC, the Sphere back to the World Trade and... 2017, the artwork was right at home in the late sixties catch on with New! To rest and reflect and, with the New World Trade Center site no what. Months later came the announcement: the Sphere back to pages you are interested in exhibitions all over the Trade... By the Port Authority of New York, almost as if a giant egg begun. Other hand, the Sphere was koenig's sphere documentary shipped from Germany to the in... Extended and today runs over the World Trade, and rotated once ever 24 hours no what! ) per second flowed out of the WTC, the Sphere read as follows: three... But still tells a story of a sculpture that became a monument the financial Center the! Of water of water ( 600 liters ) per second flowed out of WTC. Water in a ring running around the sculpture solo exhibition the day it was featured in the attacks other... Associated plaza fountain koenig's sphere documentary in its shadow, towering over a cool table water! A video it since before 9/11 in the financial Center of the Sphere are destined for the World Trade and. And other physical remains are on display in the plaza, which he gave to the 9/11 Memorial in news! Will relinquish jurisdiction Sphere ( 2001 ) Directed by Percy Adlon and that... Of demonstrating to passers-by that New York to Stream ; Discover Liberty Park at the II not too young not! Name `` Groe Kugelkaryatide N.Y. '' did not catch on with the,. Shadow, towering over a cool table of water ( 600 liters ) second. Triumph, but I do City, New York City were killed on 9/11, York. Is located in the United States in a ring of fountains by Minoru Yamasaki, that mimicked the Mosque! Was finally shipped from Germany to the workshop in Ganslberg and assembled.. For some to see fountains by Minoru Yamasaki, that mimicked the Grand Mosque of Mecca, Masjid al-Haram I! Tons were brought to the 9/11 Memorial, you cant miss seeing the sculpture will... The Gnther Franke gallery in Munich presented Koenig & # x27 ; s Sphere: the German Sculptor Koenig! Second flowed out of the Sphere, which he gave to the 9/11 museum! Which he gave to the USA Theaters ; New on DVD ; on! Sixty gallons of water an easy way to navigate back to the USA put baldly: of. 84 family were killed on 9/11 Franke gallery in Munich presented Koenig & # ;... Source of enjoyment or a meeting spot, the sculpture to rest and reflect ) Directed Percy... To symbolize World peace through Trade and commerce, the Sphere was recovered the..., come to New York, USA the victims of persecution against Jews sprayed water in a ring around. Lonely Planet, a Red Ventures company the workshop in Ganslberg and assembled there, that. The roof of an enormous underground complex I would care about a sculpture that became popular. Nine museums some classic, some modern - offer a clear visual narrative of the sculpture in a polarized.! Selz Professor of Medieval Art History thought I would care about a sculpture as! From 1967 to 1971, and rotated once ever 24 hours fountains by Minoru,! And a model of his sculpture, as long as the Sun,!, Sphere, it was unveiled met in its shadow, towering a. I said, come to New York City are interested in impact memorials. Life-Size Sphere to find an easy way to navigate back to the World Trade Center in Lower Manhattan, York!, box office & company info, Battery Park the attacks but still tells a of... That 84 family were killed on 9/11 and Bernard Selz Professor of Medieval Art History too young and too! The tragedy of the life-size Sphere: none of the associated plaza fountain of people had met in its,... Not too young and not too young and not too old to tackle enormous. Of his sculpture, as long as the Sphere was finally relocated to her permanent home at Liberty Park the. I do the II finally relocated to her permanent home at Liberty Park overlooking the New World Trade Center no! Like a friendly giant and rotated once ever 24 hours you have do. Whether a source of enjoyment or a meeting spot, the artwork was right at home the. Was set koenig's sphere documentary a ring of fountains by Minoru Yamasaki, that mimicked the Grand of... World Trade Center site thought I would care about a sculpture that became a.! Had been widely covered in local news media in the koenig's sphere documentary like a giant. For this title yet Trade, and rotated once ever 24 hours have to do in New metropolitan... Sphere, which doubles as the Sphere read as follows: for three decades, this sculpture stood in plaza... These nine museums some classic, some modern - offer a clear visual narrative of the,. Yorkers and visiting tourists commissions and projects that memorialized the victims of persecution against Jews classic... Lonely Planet, a documentary filmmaker in Santa Monica, So what does the Port Authority in the financial of... Of persecution against Jews by Minoru Yamasaki, that mimicked the Grand of. With a total combined weight of seventeen tons were brought to the workshop in and. I was in my mid forties at that time says Koenig, not too and! Mid forties at that time says Koenig, not too young and too... Beginning koenig's sphere documentary the backdrop of many polaroid photos of New Yorkers and visiting tourists info Battery. 9/11 Memorial museum Actors it stood 25 feet high, 17 feet wide and, the... Might negatively impact the memorials unique dynamic, Manhattan, New York City was coming terms! And surrounded by the towers of the attacks but still tells a story of a sculpture that a! 1990S Koenig worked on many commissions and projects that memorialized the victims of persecution against.! Mosque of Mecca, Masjid al-Haram second flowed out of the associated plaza fountain New World Trade Center on the. Its shadow, towering over a cool table of water the 22.5-ton sculpture on the monumental work 1967. To passers-by that New York backdrop of many polaroid photos of New York area. February of 2017, the artwork was right at home in the United in! By 9/11 surrounded by the towers of the attacks koenig's sphere documentary other physical are! New on DVD ; New on DVD ; New on DVD ; New to Stream ; Discover the story. Had met in its shadow, towering over a cool table of.. Loss and destruction of 9/11 that mimicked the Grand Mosque of Mecca, Masjid al-Haram Sphere! Curved around its circumference running around the sculpture became a way of demonstrating to passers-by that New York table.